12-20-2019, 07:28 AM
Başka bir yere yazdığım yorumu buraya da post ediyorum, kusura bakmayın İngilizce:
Alıntı:
Quote
I've had a long time to reflect on this, so this is me speaking with a sound of reason after I've cooled my jets so to speak.
MovieBob is right. Relax, it's fine. No, it's not an 8/10 movie (though I understand why he gave it an 8/10, the exaggerated score was an extension of his verbal defense of the movie - it is genuinely more a 6/10, and the RT score reflects this..) but it is an OK movie nonetheless.
It is deeply flawed, it has a lot of things going wrong with it, it has a lot of plot holes, it has terrible character development, and it is incredibly anti-climactic. However, a lot of these are not it's faults. The Last Jedi did not leave Rise of Skywalker anything, let alone much, to work with. Structurally, the second movie of a trilogy is supposed to build the characters and the plot while introducing the major conflict that will be resolved in the finale. What The Last Jedi did was build absolutely nothing while unsatisfactorily resolving half-baked conflicts at the cost of several plot-sensitive character deaths. This deals ROS a terrible hand. As an analogy, think of it as a director having to cram Infinity War and Endgame into the same movie. It actually manages this to the extent that its runtime allows it to be done, which is not a satisfying result but it is an accomplishment nonetheless.
The more I look at it, everything that is lacking in Rise of Skywalker and every cheap plot device it uses to build a story is because the second movie was a colossal waste of time and money on behalf of everyone involved. I don't like Rise of Skywalker, but upon reflection I don't hate it. If anything it has made me hate The Last Jedi even more if such a thing was possible.

